Does anyone have an original thought?
Guessing Koonce got profiled b/c he did not run at his pro day to get mediots to take a second look at his small college tape. If you struggle against the run at Buffalo you must suck! These guys don’t even know that he’s a good fit for LEO in Bradley’s D. No reason to bother with any rational thought, bashing the Raiders writes itself.
What a bunch of sheep. Lol
Vinny Iyer, Sporting News
Grade: D
The Raiders went for another reach here hoping that Koonce, better off playing in a 3-4, can develop into a productive situational pass rusher. He was a mid-Day 3 prospect at best on most boards.
Luke Easterling, Draft Wire
Grade: D
Another off-the-board pick for the Raiders, who bank on the upside and athleticism with Koonce here. He’ll need patience and polish before he’s ready to start at the next level.
Arif Hasan, The Athletic
Consensus Big board rank 198 (10th biggest reach)
Vic got caught in the middle b/c Brugler does not have NFL connections and whiffed on Koonce.
Vic Tafur, The Athletic
Grade: C
Koonce (6-foot-2, 249 pounds) had 14 sacks in 19 games over the past two seasons. Opinions on Koonce’s upside varied. Brugler had Koonce as his 200th overall player and gave him a seventh-round grade. The Raiders will hope he can outperform that evaluation.
PFF engaged in backfill after Kiper liked the pick. Initially they crapped on the pick.
Pro Football Focus
Grade: Average
The Raiders test the waters on a very productive pass rusher. He might not have the requisite strength right now, but the team will be hoping he adds that aspect to his game. He’s going to have to add some moves, but the bend and flexibility he possess are uncoachable traits. Can he stand up to the run at the NFL level? He was a reach of about 90 spots according to the PFF Big Board. Classic Raiders. Right now he’s a third-down player until he puts on NFL muscle.
Those who actually talk to GM’s knew better:
Mel Kiper, ESPN
I’m really high on the upside of edge rusher Malcolm Koonce (79), though he’ll need to put on some weight to play defensive end in the Raiders’ 4-3. He is relentless.
Doug Farrar, Touchdown Wire
The Raiders went back to the future by selecting a pass-rusher from Buffalo — but Malcolm Koonce is no Khalil Mack. Instead, he’s a reasonably productive player with nice athletic traits and a real need to get stronger against the run. Koonce is an appropriate third-round pick as a result.
Chris Trapasso, CBS Sports
Grade: B+
Super-bendy, Gumby-like rusher with long arms. Great combination to win around the corner. Just needs to get a little stronger at the NFL level. Good burst. Raiders continue to build the defense.