Brugler clearly missed the boat on Koonce.
33. MALCOLM KOONCE | Buffalo 6022 | 249 lbs. | SR. Peekskill, N.Y. (Archbishop Stepinac) 6/6/1998 (age 22.90) #50
BACKGROUND: Malcolm Koonce grew up in the Hudson Valley in eastern New York and started playing football in the third grade, adding rugby to his athletic resume in the eighth grade. Prior to his sophomore season, Koonce transferred to Archbishop Stepinac High School in White Plains where he joined the varsity as a tight end and defensive end (and was teammates with Syracuse’s Trill Williams). As a junior, Koonce posted 59 tackles, 8.0 tackles for loss and 5.0 sacks. He earned Second Team All-State honors as a senior with 58 tackles, 15.0 tackles for loss, 9.0 sacks and one forced fumble. Koonce helped lead Stepinac to an undefeated 2015 season and the state championship as a senior.
A no-star defensive end recruit out of high school, Koonce didn’t qualify and attended Milford Academy for one semester in the fall of 2016 to get his academics in order. He posted 47 tackles and 11.0 sacks in his one season at the prep level. Koonce was considered a two-star prep level defensive end recruit and committed to play at Buffalo, joining the program in January 2017. He opted out of the 2020 bowl game. Koonce accepted his invitation to the 2021 Senior Bowl, but was unable to participate due to a left foot injury.
YEAR (GP/GS) TKLS TFL SACK FF
2016: Milford Academy (N.Y.)
PD INT
0 0 1 0 0 0 2 0 3 0
NOTES
- First Team All-MAC
- Led MAC in sacks
- Led team in FFs
- First Team All-MAC
- Led team in sacks, TFL
- Opted out of the bowl game
2017: (12/0) 2018: (14/0) 2019: (13/13) 2020: (6/6) Total: (45/19)
16 1.0 1.0 0 30 4.0 3.0 1 34 11.0 9.0 3 30 6.5 5.0 0 110 22.5 18.0 4
HT WT ARM HAND WING 40-YD 20-YD 10-YD VJ BJ SS 3C BP COMBINE N/A (Combine canceled)
PRO DAY 6022 249 33 3/8 9 5/8 81 - - - - - - - - (no workout – left foot)
STRENGTHS: Quick upfield acceleration...quick-footed and pivots well off his rush steps to sneak into the backfield from different angles...uses his undersized body to his advantage, dipping and making himself small through gaps...shows the lateral quicks to avoid roadblocks...doesn’t have ideal length, but his hands are explosive and physical, using a violent two-hand swipe to gain his freedom...plays with a revved motor and makes plays from the backside...looks comfortable when zone dropping...led the team in sacks each of the last two seasons.
WEAKNESSES: Tweener size and lacks ideal frame/length...too easily overwhelmed and covered up by size on the edge, allowing offenses to run at him...inconsistent body control when trying to work through contact...tight through his hips, making it tough for him to quickly flatten his rush path...overaggressive with his rush attack, mistiming his swipes and losing his balance...inconsistent finishing strength as a tackler and ball carriers can stiff arm him to the ground...only a 1.5 year starter and not a fundamentally-sound player at this stage of his career...missed the Senior Bowl due to a left foot injury (January 2021).
SUMMARY: A two-year starter at Buffalo, Koonce lined up at left and right defensive end in defensive coordinator Brian Borland’s scheme, primarily standing up on the edge. He had a breakout junior season in 2019 and led the MAC with 9.0 sacks, finishing his career ranked sixth in school history with 18.0 career sacks. Although he has some stiffness, Koonce is a high-spirited, face-up pass rusher with the foot quickness and physical upper half to force his way into the backfield. He struggles to answer power at the line of scrimmage and can be inconsistent as an edge-setter.
Overall, Koonce is a tweener pass rusher with efficiency issues and limitations vs. the run, but his upfield acceleration and violent hands are intriguing building blocks for a subpackage rusher.
GRADE: 7th Round