Trade up into pick 4 poll

Pick one of the choice to move to #4

  • Daniels, Maye, JJ

    Votes: 5 41.7%
  • Daniels, JJ

    Votes: 1 8.3%
  • Daniels, Maye

    Votes: 2 16.7%
  • JJ, Maye

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Just Daniels

    Votes: 4 33.3%
  • Just Maye

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Just JJ

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • None of the above

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12
  • Poll closed .

alteredst8

Misery Loves Company
Joined
Apr 23, 2007
Messages
28,968
Reaction score
36,999
Just doing a Quick one day poll to see if there is someone you would not move up to #4 for if given the opportunity. I am assuming Williams is gone 100%. I think there are enough questions as to what happens next.

Going to work another one of those BR consensus boards. It’s been a while. I don’t plan on going past round 4 this time. As the whole thing just falls to shit after round 3-4 anyways.
 
With two picks in the 1st, both before our pick and where Penix might fall, Minn is sitting pretty to land whichever QB falls to #4 and, if they don’t want him or get outbid for him, to land Penix. Raiders only real chance might be if Minn doesn’t want Daniels enough to outbid us and would be happy with Penix.
 
That's what I'm saying. I have Daniels ranked 1, Williams and Penix ranked basically 2a and 2b. I'm not trading up for the others not because I'm scared, but because I think the better player is going later.


Scared Romance GIF by BuzzFeed
 
That's what I'm saying. I have Daniels ranked 1, Williams and Penix ranked basically 2a and 2b. I'm not trading up for the others not because I'm scared, but because I think the better player is going later.
Nothing wrong with that. I’m kind of in the same boat just different players. Just looking to see who of the QB’s do we value enough to trade up for. I probably could have done something for say pick 7 as well in a trade up. I just don’t want to over complicate it.
 
Penix is the only QB of the top 6 that I'm 100 percent comfortable will be sitting there at 13.

Assuming no trade at 4, I think McCarthy/Maye goes at 6 with Minnesota and Denver thinking real hard about Nix at 11 and 12.

All good if Penix is your guy but I think you better be prepared to make some kind of move to be guaranteed any of the others.
 
Would love to see a few more votes on this one.
 
Penix is the only QB of the top 6 that I'm 100 percent comfortable will be sitting there at 13.

Assuming no trade at 4, I think McCarthy/Maye goes at 6 with Minnesota and Denver thinking real hard about Nix at 11 and 12.

All good if Penix is your guy but I think you better be prepared to make some kind of move to be guaranteed any of the others.
Than we need to get to 5-10 on draft day. Also the Marvin thing is going to be a late rush for someone to get to the top 4…
 
Have to weigh risk reward. At what cost to move up?
 
Have to weigh risk reward. At what cost to move up?

Significant for one of the top guys but I think a small trade to leapfrog Denver is all that would be needed to secure Nix or Penix, both of which could easily be available without a trade but if the front office really loves one of them, I think it's worth the security of knowing you can get your guy. The thing with those two to me is that if you really like one, chances are the other isn't on your radar at all. They're just very different in style so the line of thought of just taking whoever falls might be less practical in a real world sense.
 
Last edited:
Significant for one of the top guys but I think a small trade to leapfrog Denver is all that would be needed to secure Nix or Penix, both of which could easily be available without a trade but if the front office really loves one of them, I think it's worth the security of knowing you can get your guy. The thing with those two to me is that if you really like one, chances are the other isn't on your radar at all. They're just very different in style so the line of thought of just taking whoever falls might be less practical in a real world sense.
But the question was about moving to no 4.
I'm not interested in Nix or Penix, at all. I would stand pat with Minshew and Aiden.
 
We would be willing to trade up for the top 4 QB’s
 
We would be willing to trade up for the top 4 QB’s

Absolutely not. I would trade the farm for Caleb or Jayden... maybe move up a couple of spots for JJ...but would absolutely positively NOT trade a single asset for Maye
 
Back
Top