I don’t think the concept of what
@Birdwell is saying is wrong. The threat of willing to and able to throw the ball over the top would loosen up the 7-8 in the box we see on most downs. I personally just don’t think we have the WR on the roster who can consistently get open on those deep routes (on time). You can show stills of a WR being open for any WR in the NFL. Doing it on time is a whole different story. Tucker is the closest we have and personally I think he gets knocked off his routes too often and the timing isn’t consistent. I just don’t see how Mendoza fixes that issue other than having a live arm that can throw it more often without it hurting the next day. You still have to connect to make it a real threat and the WR has to get open on time.
Since when has JSN -- or any WR -- been the physical receiver who is immune to press coverage. No one is.
Tucker learned from Adams and Jakobi Meyers about tools to get open on a release and beat press.
Timing is a thing for routes that break sharply in or out. Verts, posts, post/corners, seams -- they have no time. You see a favorable matchup, you throw it based on chemistry with the receiver.
Rich Gannon had guys who were half the route runner Tucker is but could read coverage, never had a plus arm, so knew to release the ball sooner than a guy with a plus arm did. If Gannon could throw deep, no reason Cousins can't. (Both had/have trouble throwing outside the numbers.)
I agree with the general thesis but I don’t see cousins as the problem as much I do the o line, the running game generally and the WRs.
I don't totally disagree with you.
At this point in the season, what can you do about the OL? Not much, though knowing how much chemistry plays a role in protection maybe not changing things every game would be an idea worth considering. While the Raider D isn't getting off run blocks, our O-line is not getting to the second level and people are running free at the backs. At one point I heard the TV guys say the Jets back had 87 yards before contact some time in the 3rd quarter. The Jets have more talent at the O-line, yes, but KK is a better OC than Frank Reich.
(And I am so old that I played against Frank Reich in high school. I went to Lancaster Catholic, Reich went to Cedar Crest. That was the Lancaster-Lebanon league. The Falcons (Cedar Crest) had a WR -- Dana Hollinger -- who was either 6'5" or 6'7" and could high jump 7'2". Red zone was a problem.)
Jeanty is has little experience running outside zone, and his injury makes it hard to run it because of the violence of the cuts good backs make in that system. Part of what he is very good at is setting up LBs and safeties from behind the line but the O-line is actually worse than last year at run blocking. Changing from power-man/inside zone/duo to outside zone isn't an easy transition. Mike Washington likely has better vision than he's showing but right now he's picking a hole and going.
Hard to judge the WRs when the QB won't throw to them -- and that's three years of QBs not throwing (or in Geno's case not completing) deep balls.
Tre Tucker does not get magically open and based on three games get on pace for a thousand yard season. Jailen Nailor didn't wake up Sunday and become a new guy. When Cousins looks they're open, just needs to make the throws.