I never saw Juice play, but McFadden reminds me of Marcus Allen from highlights I've seen in that he's such a smooth, beautiful runner and a naturally gifted football player, without any bullshit (on the field, I mean). Like how McFadden carries without a glove, like Marcus, and is good enough to make Tomlinson's little halfback passes seem pitiful.
DMC is faster of course, and I think Marcus had better peripheral vision and shuffling elusiveness, but as far as the way the two run, the way they stagger their feet and use their arms, I see him as that kind of gorgeous runner.
It is harder to evaluate him with that offense, though.
I think the one thing that is clear, though, is that even with Dorsey's health problems considered, McFadden has more potential to be SPECIAL than any of the other potentially high picks that would be suitable to be looked at for this team.
Given the rumors about Jerry Jones and his love of the Arkansas kid, I'd love to see if Al could hold his buddy over the barrel and get Dallas' two first-rounders and a bunch of other picks later on, and maybe even a lineman or two.
I know some here don't think much of DeSean Jackson at the next level, but I look at it like there's a big gap as far as value between him and the next receiver or two with 'game-changing' speed in this class, and if they could trade down and get him, and then an OT like Oher or Baker, all the better.
Because even with all the problems on defense (like Tony Montana said... other teams have to look at this defense and go, "...that guy sof'..."), with all the money invested in J-Rock, IMO, this team has to do everything in its power to get him off on the right foot.
Sign Berrian, sign Crayton, get linemen in here, yada.