It's Official
Lombardi, Raiders part
Posted by Jerry McDonald - NFL Writer on May 9th, 2007
Personnel executive Mike Lombardi is out in Oakland, which at this point is like reporting spring will give way to summer next month.
In other words, no surprises, and also no way to know how it affects the Raiders because of their method of operation.
Lombardi joined the Raiders personnel department in 1999, eventually ascending to "senior personnel executive." He took over some of the duties of senior assistant Bruce Allen upon Allen's departure to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, so it's clear he was a valued member of the organization by Al Davis.
Exactly how good Lombardi is as a personnel man is hard to determine because when it came to speaking on the record, he adhered to Oakland's in-house policy. There are those who believe Lombardi, along with now retired Chet Franklin, were at the core of Oakland's ability to land veteran free agents at bargain prices when the team won three consecutive division titles from 2000 through 2002.
But since he was never out front and open like the 49ers Scot McCloughan, or others in the league, the credit basically went to Davis and Jon Gruden. Davis, after all, makes the final call. Only he knows how much he leaned on Lombardi, and he's not saying.
Lombardi's slow exit began the moment Bobby Petrino turned down the job as Raiders head coach. It was Lombardi who gave Davis the hard sell, with Petrino even being offered the job.
When Petrino said, "thanks, but no thanks," Davis turned to Art Shell. Shell knew Lombardi wanted Petrino. He either suspected or knew for a fact Lombardi wasn't on board with the Shell program.
Let's face facts here _ Lombardi was right. Shell is a good man, but made two colossal blunders in hiring a staff. He made Tom Walsh a loyalty hire as offensive coordinator (he was fired along with Walsh from the Raiders in 1994). An even bigger error was Shell's decision to make Irv Eatman and Jackie Slater co-offensive line coaches instead of bringing in one experienced voice.
Lombardi, Shell believed, floated stories to selected media members critical of Walsh and the Shell regime. Shell reacted angrily, believing Lombardi was stabbing him in the back, and said as much with an unprompted speech to local writers in which he didn't name Lombardi but made it clear who he was talking about.
I can't say for certain whether he didn't, because Lombardi never said those things to me.
Davis has the reputation of being heavy-handed, but he does invite discussion and debate. He thinks arguing within the walls of the complex is not necessarily a bad thing. If Lombardi ever voiced his concerns to Davis regarding the Shell regime, and then similar things wound up in the media in the form of anonymous sources, the only he way he stuck around as long as he did was keeping his name out of it as much as possible.
If Lombardi had any chance of holding on, it ended when Lane Kiffin came aboard as head coach. Kiffin was hired in part becuase he has a background in personnel as a recruiting coordinator in USC.
Kiffin, in turn brought in Mark Jackson as "director of pro football development," helping with administrative duties so he concentrate on personnel as well as X's and O's.
It's doubtful the whole Shell affair will have any effect on where Lombardi will land. A few teams may shy away from Lombardi, but others will say, `Hey, it's the Raiders. You never know what really happened there."
Still others reside in the AFC West, and how much could it hurt to have someone aboard with extensive knowledge of Oakland's operation?