POSTED 8:24 p.m. EST, December 21, 2006
SHELL OUT IN OAKLAND?
Though we're in Columbus, Ohio for a couple of days and unable to watch NFLN (thanks for nothing, league and Time Warner), several readers tell us that there's a report on the league's in-house television joint that Raiders coach Art Shell will be fired after the season.
We're not sure we buy it. Although it's our understanding that significant changes are coming for the 2-12 Raiders, it's also our understanding that no decisions have been made -- and that the decisions will be made by owner Al Davis after the season.
Our guess? Raiders personnel executive Mike Lombardi could very well be putting out the word to the media that Shell is getting sh-t-canned, possibly in retaliation for Shell's recent complaints about a traitor among the Raiders, and most league observers believe that Shell was talking about Lombardi.
Lombardi also might be motivated by the fact that rumors are rampant that Lombardi will get the heave-ho, rumors which Lombardi might believe Shell is circulating.
And we're not sure that Shell deserves to be fired. Yeah, he never should have hired Tom Walsh to serve as offensive coordinator, but the Raiders' defense has been very good this season.
Stay tuned.
-------------------------------------------------------------------
NFL Network: Shell is gone
Posted by Jerry McDonald - NFL Writer on Thursday at 5:01 pm
I found out about Art Shell's impending doom before getting the chance to ask him about it.
It wasn't until I got home and a colleague phoned me with the news that the NFL Network's Adam Schefter was reporting that Al Davis would fire Shell at the end of the season.
Schefter reported this during the Network's "Total Access'' show leading up to the broadcast of the Minnesota-Green Bay game.
The Raiders immediately fired off a press release which the studio host Rich Eisen read on the air.
"Adam Schefter has always been a false rumor monger with respect to the Raiders and anti-Raider based on his relationship with Denver and Mike Shanahan. No decisions have been made relative to the 2007 Oakland Raiders will they be made for some time. Adam Schefter could not have gotten his information from a reliable source because there's only one reliable source, and he doesn't trust Adam.''
Schefter's response?
"Typical Raiders. Getting personal. But the fact remains nowhere in that statement did it say that Art Shell will be back as the Raiders head coach. If they really wanted to attack me and make me look really bad, then they would say, `Art Shell will be our head coach in 2007.' Which he will not be. The plan right now is to release Art Shell after the season. He has one year remaining on his contract at $1.8 million and the plan right now is to fire Art Shell.''
A few notes on Shell's allegedly imminent demise:
– Schefter covered the Broncos first for the Rocky Mountain News and then for the Denver Post. He's written books with Shanahan and Bill Romanowski.
As such, he's more wired into the Broncos than he is to the Raiders, but to assume he is doing this deliberately because he's a Bronco fan is ridiculous.
This is probably an unpopular opinion for this forum, but the whole "Raider hater'' thing is for the most part nonsense.
The Raiders are criticized because the Raiders deserve to be criticized. They've been horrible for four years now. The same people who shout "Raider-hater'' are usually the same ones ripped the media from jumping on the bandwagon in the three-year run of AFC West titles from 2000 through 2002.
Does that mean I think Schefter is right? I think he thinks he is. But the phrase "the plan now'' gives Schefter some wiggle room. He can easily report at a later date that the plan changed. If he's first with that story, he can claim that as a scoop as well.
I'm not going to attack Schefter. He makes a lot more money than I do and has broken plenty of stories over the years.
– What is a false rumor monger, anyway? Doesn't the term "monger'' imply the rumors are false?
– The Raiders release, done in typical heavy-handed silver and black fashion, buries the lead, as they say in the business:
"Adam Schefter could not have gotten his information from a reliable source because there's only one reliable source, and he doesn't trust Adam.''
Let me be the first to break the story that Al Davis did not talk with Adam Schefter. And if you don't get this information from Al Davis, then you're taking a risk in going with the story.
You could be right. The Raiders could end up 2-14, after all. Dumping the coach is not a stretch.
– Schefter's response that the if the Raiders wanted to refute his rumor they would announce Shell is returning for another season is absurd.
What multi-million dollar business enterprise makes a policy commitment to refute an on-air story that has no attribution?
Maybe Davis doesn't know what he's going to do yet. Lord knows he operates slowly when making decisions. The guess here is he is trying to figure out if it is sensible to make dramatic changes to the offensive staff but retain Shell. I think that's what he would like to do, ideally.
But if the Raiders completely fall apart in the last two games, his hand may be forced.
– The real entertainment comes Saturday when NFL Network is in town to cover the game. Hope they already have their credientials and parking passes.