The Last Defense

Discussion in 'Raiders Discussion' started by RF34, Jun 25, 2020.

  1. RF34

    RF34 Habitual Line Stepper

    Messages:
    11,244
    Likes Received:
    15,301
    The Last Defense: Looking back on a decade of Raiders defensive ineptitude
    [​IMG]
    By Vic Tafur 3h ago
    Fresh off the success of “The Last Dance” docuseries on Michael Jordan’s Bulls dynasty, ESPN has unearthed some never-before-seen footage of the Raiders defense from 2010-19. Viewers can experience again and even more vividly what it was like when the Raiders gave up seven touchdown passes to Nick Foles or when they had linebacker Rolando McClain cover Calvin Johnson with the game on the line.

    No? Not interested?

    Forget Jordan and his cigar. You would be missing a great scene when McClain brought in his baby daughter to work one day and begrudgingly met with reporters for a rare chat. At one point, the girl cried out and McClain looked down at her and said, without the hint of a grin, “She hates reporters, too.”

    ESPN is not really doing a show on the Raiders defense, but the network did find it necessary to crown them as the worst defense in the NFL for the last decade.

    (What is the trophy for that? A brass sieve? A threadbare welcome mat?)

    It’s a well-deserved honor, no doubt.

    The Raiders were at or near the bottom of the league in every category — last in points allowed (26.2 per game), 29th in yards per play allowed (5.7), 31st in takeaways (206) and last in passer rating against (94.7), per the Associated Press’ Josh Dubow — and they did it with a stumbling flair and brash personality that annually defied logic. Like, who can get forget when in 2014, in London, the Dolphins bunched three receivers on one side of the field and the Raiders had one cornerback on them?

    Even the good times — we counted, there were five — were scary.

    Like when the 0-10 Raiders stunned the Chiefs in 2014, but rookie Khalil Mack and Sio Moore were still dancing after a third-down sack in the final minute when the ball was hiked for the next play. Alert veteran Justin Tuck called timeout just before the snap to prevent a penalty — and the Chiefs getting a free fourth-down play against a nine-man defense — though it probably took a few years off of the lives of Tuck and Charles Woodson. (They both told Moore after the game that if the Raiders would have lost, one of them would have fought him in the locker room.)

    The other four defensive highlights last decade were Michael Huff’s 2011 game-sealing interception in Houston the day after owner Al Davis died, the Thursday night win that same year over the Chargers when Kamerion Wimbley (four sacks) and Richard Seymour put the Raiders in first place in the AFC West, the Mack five-sack game in Denver in 2015 and the game a year later when Mack had a sack, an interception, a forced fumble and a touchdown to beat the Panthers.

    The Raiders simply had trouble drafting good defensive players as well as signing free agents who weren’t just looking for a final payday. All told, the Raiders had only five defensive players named to the Pro Bowl from 2010-19 — Nnamdi Asomugha, Seymour, Mack, Woodson and … wait for it, Reggie Nelson. Only Asomugha and Mack made first-team All-Pro.

    Mostly the Raiders had a bunch of overachievers and underachievers who both fell short. And all the coaches they hired and fired just weren’t up to the task — not even the two (out of six) head coaches who were defensive guys, Dennis Allen and Jack Del Rio.

    The Raiders had six defensive coordinators the last decade — John Marshall, Chuck Bresnahan, Jason Tarver, Ken Norton Jr., John Pagano and Paul Guenther. The jury is still out on Guenther in Year 3, but he did crack the top 20 in yards allowed last season — the first time in seven seasons the Raiders have done that — and this offseason is the first time that Jon Gruden has spent close to half of the salary cap on defense.

    Since we’re not doing a 10-part TV series on the Raiders defense, I figured we’ll look at 10 moments from the last decade, highlighting how a confident group of players, feeding off of an organizational history of toughness, spirit and defiance … simply got trucked by opposing offenses most Sundays:

    10. The five-safety defense
    I covered all six defensive coordinators and the best one was probably Marshall my first year on the beat in 2010. The Raiders ranked 11th in yards per game allowed (322.8) and 20th in points per game allowed (23.2) but had trouble stopping the run (29th in rushing defense to counter the No. 2 ranked passing defense). And first-round pick McClain was not the answer, something that was clear right out of the gate.

    Six games in, I asked Marshall about McClain and he said, “I tell (the players), I don’t want a bunch of iron deer on the lawn, cardboard cutouts (that say), ‘Oh, I’m doing what Coach said. I’m not making any plays, but I’m doing that.’”

    McClain was stiff, but his lack of development was not the reason Davis had Marshall walk the plank after the season. No, that was because of the Dec. 12 game at Jacksonville. Marshall sat Asomugha, a first-team All-Pro cornerback, for a play and tried a five-safety defense, and then watched as somebody named Jason Hill beat Huff for a 48-yard touchdown. That proved to be the difference in a 38-31 loss that ruined Darren McFadden’s finest hour as a Raider — the running back had 123 yards rushing and two touchdowns, and 86 receiving yards and another touchdown.

    I remember asking Asomugha after the game if he was injured that play and he looked at me with a sad grin and raised eyebrow, followed by a resigned smile. That was the face of the Raiders defense the last decade.

    9. Rams 52, Raiders 0
    The late Tony Sparano, who took over for the fired Allen in 2014, was close to shedding the interim tag and becoming the full-time coach. The Raiders finished 3-3 after the 0-10 start and the players believed in him, but one of those three losses smelled worse than a skunk eating a microwaved tuna sandwich. A week after beating the Chiefs for their first win, the hungover Raiders went to St. Louis and lost 52-0 to the Rams on Nov. 30.

    Not the Kurt Warner-Marshall Faulk-Isaac Bruce Rams. The Shaun Hill-Tre Mason-Stedman Bailey Rams. Mason finished with a combined 164 yards and three touchdowns — one more than he would have the final 17 games of his career after that.

    https://twitter.com/NFL/status/539124326931644417

    8. The 1-on-3 coverage
    Previously in 2014, the Raiders went to London on Sept. 28 and were down 38-7 to the Dolphins by the third quarter. We mentioned the 1-on-3 coverage earlier, but many European fans left the stadium that day thinking that Miami quarterback Ryan Tannehill was the Michael Jordan of football.

    Allen and his family made the long, uncomfortable flight home on the team charter and then he was fired. Mark Davis never cared for Allen — he thought he was a little smug — and general manager Reggie McKenzie never did get a second chance at hiring a coach. Del Rio was 100 percent Davis’ choice after that embarrassing loss to the Rams soured him on Sparano.

    7. Playing McClain against the Dolphins
    Hue Jackson will say that he had no control of the defense the year he was head coach, and he is right — Bresnahan was an Al Davis guy who came along with the keys to the big office. But Jackson did make a decision on the defense that had some lasting effects — he decided to play McClain against the Dolphins on Dec. 4, 2011, the week after the linebacker was arrested in Alabama on charges of third-degree assault and discharging a firearm (he was eventually found guilty, though on appeal the charges were dismissed when the victim declined to pursue charges). The reason: Jackson didn’t have any faith in backup linebacker Darryl Blackstock.

    The Raiders got blown out 34-14 — they did often in Miami — and some players started questioning Jackson. “Next man up” is sacred stuff to players in the locker room, especially when the original man up is being compared to lawn deer.

    The Raiders lost three games in a row to erase a 7-4 record and the momentum from the Carson Palmer trade.

    6. The football burial
    Sparano wanted to shake things up when he took over the 0-4 team in 2014, so he called a team meeting and literally buried a football — and the team’s old ways — on the side of the practice field out back at the team facility.

    https://twitter.com/Bookerc94/status/1021093698472308737

    The Raiders lost their next six games. The ball was dug up the next year and was not placed in the glass case in the main lobby.
     
    Crow likes this.
  2. RF34

    RF34 Habitual Line Stepper

    Messages:
    11,244
    Likes Received:
    15,301
    5. The Nick Mullens game
    This should probably be higher. The Nov. 1, 2018, game in Santa Clara is the darkest moment of Gruden’s two years back, as the 49ers backup quarterback looked like Joe Montana against a defense that appeared to quit. Mullens completed 16 of 22 passes for 262 yards and three touchdowns as the 49ers took a 31-3 lead with nine minutes remaining in the third quarter.

    https://twitter.com/NFL/status/1058339655941124096

    Luckily for the Raiders, 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan likes Gruden and called off the dogs. The loss dropped the Raiders to 1-7, and while many players said the preseason trade of Mack for future picks was a gut punch, the Mullens game was the uppercut knockout blow.

    4. McClain covering Calvin Johnson
    The first reaction when you see McClain covering Detroit’s Calvin Johnson 40 yards downfield is that there had to be a communication or assignment error. That is, once the shock wore off.

    The Raiders blew a 27-14 lead with six minutes left in this Dec. 18, 2011, game to the Lions, who drove 98 yards to win thanks largely to one play. Matthew Stafford just lobbed the ball up toward Johnson, arguably the best receiver in the game at that point. Maybe Stafford saw that McClain was chasing after Johnson and that the Raiders were donating 48 yards.

    No, it wasn’t a communication mistake between players. Johnson was McClain’s guy. That was the zone defense that Bresnahan drew it up, hoping the pass rush got to Stafford first.

    Only the Raiders.

    3. The Jamaal Charles game
    There are a lot of great personalities and memorable faces from the Raiders defense of 2010-19. That defensive line of Seymour, Tommy Kelly and John Henderson was a treat to talk to, as were Tuck and Antonio Smith later. The late Quentin Groves was one of the most positive people I have ever met in my life. Huff never lived up to being a first-round pick, but he would switch from safety to corner and back if that was what the team needed. After he was gone, the Raiders had a new secondary almost every season — all good guys who quickly proved why they were stopgap measures.

    One of the many bright faces that the Raiders were excited about was linebacker Miles Burris. He made plays at San Diego State, but no matter how much extra time Tarver spent with him, Burris got swallowed up by blocks and was always a step late. On Dec, 15. 2013, he had the misfortune of being matched up against Chiefs running back Jamaal Charles. Good news — Charles only had 20 yards rushing and a touchdown. Bad news — Charles had eight catches for 195 yards and four touchdowns with Burris in pursuit. In three quarters, as the Raiders lost 56-31.

    2. The Doug Martin game
    Much like the Lions game and the Charles game, the bottom two moments for the Raiders defense came at home — Oakland fans deserved better and now they have to fly to Las Vegas to chase that dream.

    On Nov. 4, 2012, Buccaneers running back Doug Martin ran for 251 yards and four touchdowns in a 42-32 win over the Raiders. It was one of the many times that a disgusted (and hilarious) Kelly would face reporters and utter the same three words to describe his defense.

    “Stop, stop, boom.”

    1. The Nick Foles game
    There are eight players who share the NFL record for most touchdown passes in a game with seven. Nick Foles is one of them, and the former Eagles quarterback would have had 10 on Nov. 3, 2013, if the Raiders offense had put up more of a fight in the 49-20 loss.

    Foles completed 22 of 28 passes for 406 yards and seven touchdowns before calling it a day with four minutes to go in the third quarter. Three of the touchdowns went to Riley Cooper, two against Raiders first-round pick D.J. Hayden. Hayden was also beat deep by DeSean Jackson. Hayden went on to be a decent player, but days like that gave him the bust label early and Raiders fans don’t change their minds easily.

    Allen will tell you to this day that he had nothing to work with, which is a cop-out but also not a lie. His starting defense that day was Jason Hunter, Vance Walker, Pat Sims and Lamarr Houston up front, Nick Roach and Kevin Burnett at linebacker and a nickel secondary of Mike Jenkins, Tracy Porter, Hayden, Brandian Ross and Woodson.

    “There’s not a whole lot you can tell them,” Allen said after the game. “At the end of the day, that was an old-fashioned butt whipping. We have to move on from it.”

    Maybe … the Raiders’ move to Las Vegas and a new decade will do the trick.
     
    Curly Howard, raiderfreak7 and Crow like this.
  3. gst8

    gst8 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    46,512
    Likes Received:
    67,384
    Appropriate bit of irony there Vic writing an article about a decade of ineptitude.
     
    Rainman56, Birdwell, Sleet and 11 others like this.
  4. Madturk

    Madturk Barry McCockinner

    Messages:
    57,167
    Likes Received:
    47,033
    :lmao:
     
  5. TheNextStep

    TheNextStep TX BBQ > KC BBQ

    Messages:
    9,053
    Likes Received:
    13,867
    Made me think to myself, “Forget last drive with the game on the line... think more “up 10 midway through the third”.... when was the last time we had a defense where I thought at that point that we had the game won?”

    John Parella started for that defense.
     
    Sleet, Solve4X, raiderfreak7 and 2 others like this.
  6. Armyr8rfan

    Armyr8rfan Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    19,458
    Likes Received:
    19,914
    What sucks is that is probably his most accurate and well written article in about that same time span. It also sucks that as I read that article I got mental images from every one of those fuckin’ games lmao...
     
    Sleet, Solve4X, Curly Howard and 4 others like this.
  7. Crow

    Crow CROWVID-19: The F-U Flu

    Messages:
    57,801
    Likes Received:
    52,182
    Thanks, Vic. :raiderbag:
     
    Sleet and Armyr8rfan like this.
  8. Dummy McIdiot

    Dummy McIdiot Nincompoop

    Messages:
    25,491
    Likes Received:
    25,079
    TLDR.
     
    CrossBones likes this.
  9. CrossBones

    CrossBones The Black Pearl

    Messages:
    60,697
    Likes Received:
    53,218
    Cliffs Notes version: WE SUCK
     
  10. Crow

    Crow CROWVID-19: The F-U Flu

    Messages:
    57,801
    Likes Received:
    52,182
    And we're quite good at it.
     
  11. Dummy McIdiot

    Dummy McIdiot Nincompoop

    Messages:
    25,491
    Likes Received:
    25,079
    Figured as much...
     
  12. boknowsvt

    boknowsvt A Noble Spirit Embiggens The Smallest Man

    Messages:
    11,698
    Likes Received:
    14,735
    Watching Miles Burris get burned multiple times by Jamal Charles on the same wheel route was painful.
     
    Sleet, Raidervinny, Madturk and 3 others like this.
  13. Crow

    Crow CROWVID-19: The F-U Flu

    Messages:
    57,801
    Likes Received:
    52,182
    Fixed.
     
  14. CrossBones

    CrossBones The Black Pearl

    Messages:
    60,697
    Likes Received:
    53,218
    ...and how long has this “sucking” bullshit been going on?
     
  15. cruedi

    cruedi Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    5,566
    Likes Received:
    6,005
    I remember one play against the chiefs where Sio Moore got the Charles in the backfield and tossed him towards the sideline and then started celebrating. Charles didn’t go down but fortunately Burris kept playing and knocked him down. Sio,so much talent so little brains
     
    Rainman56 and raiderfreak7 like this.
  16. Crow

    Crow CROWVID-19: The F-U Flu

    Messages:
    57,801
    Likes Received:
    52,182
    My jaw hurts, if that tells you anything.
     
  17. Byron2112

    Byron2112 4.65...

    Messages:
    20,859
    Likes Received:
    20,212
    I forgot whatshisname was a defensive coach... God I can't even remember the guys name, or barely his face even... then Del Rio was a defensive coach I suppose..

    didn't move the needle one bit... sad... Raider sad
     
    Solve4X likes this.
  18. Byron2112

    Byron2112 4.65...

    Messages:
    20,859
    Likes Received:
    20,212
    was that the game Charles scored 3-4 TD's?

    that one knocked me outta FF playoffs.... Raiders even screwing me in real life, costing me money..:mad:
     
  19. godeep811

    godeep811 University of Mars

    Messages:
    15,321
    Likes Received:
    18,237
    That entire article in The Athletic was extremely sad.

    I remember the 80's when the Raider defense was unreal. Haynes and Hayes on the outside. Terror coming from the defensive line. Here's an excerpt from a 1990 Jim Murray article on Howie Long:

    "But Howie Long (as well as Greg Townsend) is a throwback. Howie was a member of that man-eating cast of characters - Lyle Alzado and John Matuszak were the other two- who terrorized quarterbacks in the league for most of the decade.

    This Terrible Threesome left a trail of quarterbacks bleaching in the sun like cattle bones in Death Valley before time broke them up."

    [​IMG]
     
    Raidervinny and Solve4X like this.
  20. NIPS

    NIPS Well-Hung Member

    Messages:
    25,606
    Likes Received:
    23,852
    Defense has been dogshit for 20 years
     
    Sleet, Nobodyinparticular and Madturk like this.