Scoring the AFC West draft using the 2017 Concensus Big Board and the new Draft Value Chart.
1st round
Dolts #7 (425.5): Williams #11 (357.62)
Chefs #27+#91+'18 1st (350.61): Mahomes #30 (196.31)
Donks #20 (269.18): Bolles #27 (215.81)
Raiders #24 (237.35): Conley #16 (305.41)
Best player/value: Dolts/Raider
Worst player/value: Chefs
2nd round
Dolts #38 (157.49): Lamp #17 (295.92)
Donks #51 (112.03): Walker #91 (43.96)
Raiders #56 (98.27): Obi #16 (161.67)
Chefs #59 (90.84): TKO #111 (28.22)
Best player/value: Dolts
Worst player/value: Chefs/Donks
3rd round
Dolts #71 (68.30): Feeney #49 (118.06)
Donks #82 (53.60): Henderson #68 (72.97)
Chefs #104+#132+#245 (52.09): Hunt #95 (40.26)
Raiders #88 (46.97): Vandy #118 (24.15)
Best player/value: Dolts
Worst player/value: Raiders
4th round
Dolts #113 (27.00): Jenkins #157 (10.14)
Donks #126+#238+#252 (23.10): Butt #82+McKenzie #230 (55.60)
Raiders #129 (18.91): Sharpe #151 (11.58)
Chefs #170+#180 (13.66): Cheesen #213 (2.91)
Best player/value: Donks
Worst player/value: Chefs
5th round:
Dolts #151 (11.58): King #67 (74.59)
Raiders #168 (7.93): Lee #207 (3.33)
Donks #177+Bibbs (11.14): '9ers' '18 4th (14.47)
Chefs #216 + O'Shaughnessy (17.20): Eligwe #250+ (1.00)
Best player/value: Dolts
Worst player/value: Chefs
6th round:
Dolts #190 (4.86): Tevi #245 (1.43)
Donks #203 (3.64): Henderson 250+ (1.00)
Raiders #208 (3.26): Luani #250++Ware #250+ (2.00)
Chefs #218 (2.61): McQuay III #250+ (1.00)
Best player/value: Raiders
Worst player/value: Chefs/Donks
7th round:
Dolts #225 (2.23): Rochell #183 (5.68)
Raiders #242+#244 (2.99): Hood #250+Hester #228 (3.09)
Donks #253 (1.00): Kelly #236 (1.75)
Chefs (T): N/A
Best player/value: Dolts
Worst player/value: Chefs
Score Card: Resources/Value
Dolts: 696.96/863.44 (+166.48)
Chefs: 527.01/269.70 (-257.31)
Donks: 473.69/405.56 (-68.13)
Raiders: 415.68/511.23 (+99.55)
Notes:
1. Dolts had the most resources and spent well
2. Reid tried to outsmart the board the entire draft
3. Red got value early, filled spots thereafter
4. Horseface underperformed but got Butt
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1EKkKqW_dmjBiNlBWzZunXaXVE_0H-PuOYt7mZorx0q8/htmlview
https://www.google.com/amp/www.pats...ating-a-brand-new-nfl-draft-value-trade-chart